Amit Shah, the Home Minister of India, has expressed his belief that reservation for Muslims is unconstitutional. His stance is rooted in several arguments, including:

• India's Constitution forbids discrimination on the basis of religion, so providing reservation for Muslims could be seen as a violation of this principle.
• Reservation should be based on social and economic backwardness, not religion. Since Muslims are not a homogeneous group in terms of socio-economic status, a blanket reservation may not be appropriate.
• Providing reservation for Muslims could create tension and resentment among other religious groups who may see it as preferential treatment.
• Shah has also argued that there are already many government schemes and initiatives in place to benefit the Muslim community, such as scholarships for minority students and programmes to improve education and employment opportunities.

Overall, Amit Shah's stance on the issue of reservation for Muslims is based on constitutional principles and concerns about potential conflict between different religious groups.