Why are rigid, statutory fiscal targets getting discredited globally

The Finance Secretary claims that rigid, statutory fiscal targets are getting discredited globally. Discuss the reasons behind this trend.
  • Complex economic conditions: Rigid, statutory fiscal targets tend to oversimplify the complexities of economic conditions. The global economy is constantly evolving, and fixed targets may not be able to adapt to changing circumstances.
  • Unpredictable events: Global events, such as natural disasters or financial crises, can significantly impact fiscal outcomes. Rigid targets may fail to account for these unexpected events, resulting in unrealistic or unattainable goals.
  • Limited policy flexibility: Setting inflexible targets restricts the government's ability to respond to economic fluctuations effectively. It hampers their ability to implement counter-cyclical policies, adjust spending, or pursue long-term investments.
  • Social needs: Rigid targets may prioritize short-term fiscal stability while neglecting important social needs, such as healthcare, education, or infrastructure development. This imbalance can lead to public dissatisfaction and hinder sustainable economic growth.
  • Political pressures: Governments face pressure from various interest groups. Setting overly strict targets can be politically challenging, as it may require unpopular measures or austerity measures that impact the electorate negatively.
Overall, the discrediting of rigid, statutory fiscal targets globally stems from their inability to accommodate complex economic realities, respond to unpredictable events, restrict policy flexibility, neglect social needs, and succumb to political pressures.
Answered a year ago
Krishna Preparing for Civil Services