How does the 'One Nation One Election' concept affect India's federal structure

Speakers at a democracy convention believe that 'One Nation One Election' undermines India's federal structure.
  • 'One Nation One Election' concept refers to the synchronization of all elections in India – from panchayat to parliament – to be held simultaneously.
  • This concept aims to bring efficiency and reduce election-related costs, but it has implications for India's federal structure.
  • The federal structure of India is based on the principle of decentralization of power, with states having their own legislative and executive authorities.
  • By synchronizing all elections, the concept undermines the autonomy of state governments, as they will have to align their schedules with the central government.
  • It may lead to a dominance of national issues and parties in state elections, thereby diluting regional voices and concerns.
  • The concept may also favor larger and better-resourced political parties, hindering smaller or regional parties from effectively participating in multiple elections simultaneously.
  • Furthermore, the diversity of India, including regional disparities and socio-economic variations, necessitates separate election cycles to address particular regional issues and aspirations.
  • A unified election system could also lead to a single-party dominance at both the national and state levels, limiting the role of alternative voices and checks on power.
Overall, the 'One Nation One Election' concept, while aiming for streamlining and efficiency, could potentially undermine India's federal structure by diminishing the autonomy of states, diluting regional voices, and limiting the role of smaller parties.
Answered a year ago
Arun Preparing for Civil Services