Is the Indian government discriminating against minorities

Critically analyze PM Modi's statement about no discrimination against minorities in India and the actual ground reality.
There is ongoing debate and controversy regarding the extent of discrimination against minorities in India and the credibility of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's statement that there is no discrimination against minorities in the country. A critical analysis of this issue can be presented in point form:
  • PM Modi's statement may reflect the intentions and aspirations of the government to ensure equal treatment for all citizens, irrespective of their religious or ethnic background.
  • However, ground reality suggests that incidents of discrimination, particularly against religious minorities such as Muslims and Christians, have been reported. These incidents include hate crimes, mob violence, and social marginalization.
  • The controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), enacted by the government, has also sparked concerns as it is seen by some as discriminatory towards Muslims, while favoring Hindu immigrants.
  • The National Register of Citizens (NRC) exercise, conducted in Assam, has affected marginalized communities, including Muslims, who are struggling to provide necessary documentation to prove their Indian citizenship.
  • The attacks on freedom of speech and dissent, targeting journalists and activists, have created an atmosphere where minority voices feel suppressed, further indicating a potential discrimination issue.
In conclusion, while PM Modi's statement may reflect the desired vision of the government, the ground reality suggests that there are incidents and policies that raise concerns about discrimination against minorities in India.
Answered a year ago
Amrita Preparing for Civil Services